E Kemon Mamata Dipak Kumar Ghosh ((top))
However, the core narrative of E Kemon Mamata argues that the reality of her governance drastically diverged from the idealistic promises made during the historic "Ma Mati Manush" campaign. Released around the early anniversaries of the TMC government taking power, the book documents what the author labels as a rapid shift toward administrative centralization, impulsive decision-making, and autocratic party governance. Key Themes Explored in the Text
: Ghosh highlights what he describes as "illogical and hope-raising promises" made by Banerjee that failed to materialize.
Ghosh’s writings, which also include related volumes like Mamata Banerjee-As I Have Known Her or The Goddess That Failed and Sada Mamata Kalo Mamata , serve as a documented critique of the political promises, internal contradictions, and leadership style of the TMC chairperson. The Author’s Profile: Who is Dipak Kumar Ghosh?
A detailed English translation/counterpart providing documentary evidence of his 13-year journey with Banerjee.
দীপক কুমার ঘোষ মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়কে নিয়ে মোট দুটি বই লিখেছেন। ‘মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায় কে জেমন দেখেছি’ (মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায় কেমন দেখেছি) ছিল তার প্রথম বই। এই বইয়ের বর্ণনা অনুযায়ী, লেখক ‘তথাকথিত মূল্যবোধ-ভিত্তিক রাজনীতিতে জড়িত’ রাজনৈতিক নেতাদের প্রকৃত চেহারা উন্মোচনের জন্যই বইটি লেখেন। এটি ছিল মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়ের ব্যক্তিত্ব ও কর্মপদ্ধতি নিয়ে লেখকের ব্যক্তিগত পর্যবেক্ষণের সংকলন। এই প্রথম বইয়ের পরেই তিনি দ্বিতীয় সংস্করণ অর্থাৎ ‘এ কেমন মমতা’ রচনা করেন, যা ছিল একটি ফলো-আপ বা দ্বিতীয় খণ্ড। e kemon mamata dipak kumar ghosh
বইয়ের সবচেয়ে আলোচিত অধ্যায় লেখা হয় ২০২৫ সালের মে মাসে। কৌস্তব বাগচি যখন বইয়ের কিছু অংশ সামাজিক মাধ্যমে আপলোড করেন, তখন তার বিরুদ্ধে টালিগঞ্জ থানায় একটি লিখিত অভিযোগ দায়ের করা হয়। অভিযোগপত্রে দাবি করা হয়, বইটিতে মুখ্যমন্ত্রীর বিরুদ্ধে “নোংরা ও কুরুচিপূর্ণ” মন্তব্য রয়েছে এবং এই পেজগুলো পোস্ট করা একজন নারীর সম্মান হরণের শামিল। অভিযোগকারীর বক্তব্য, “এই ব্যক্তি সব সীমা অতিক্রম করে একজন মহিলা মুখ্যমন্ত্রীকে অসম্মান করেছেন। প্রয়াত লেখকের বই উদ্ধৃত করে তিনি লেখকের কথাগুলো পুনর্ব্যক্ত করেছেন এবং একজন নারীর মর্যাদাকে আঘাত করেছেন।”
"E Kemon Mamata" stands out in the landscape of Indian political literature because it avoids superficial critique. By backing his observations with firsthand encounters and administrative contexts, Dipak Kumar Ghosh created an enduring historical archive. Whether read as a cautionary tale on the corrupting nature of absolute political power or used as a academic text on West Bengal's contemporary history, the book remains an indispensable read for anyone trying to understand the complex machinery running behind the scenes of Bengal's leadership. Share public link
The book (translated as "What Kind of Mamata is This?" ) is a highly controversial and critical political exposé written by the late Dipak Kumar Ghosh , a former Indian Administrative Service (IAS) officer and a two-term Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) from West Bengal. Published originally around 2013 by Kolkata Prokashon, the book serves as an unfiltered, insider account detailing the author's "unlucky 13 years" of close association with Mamata Banerjee and her political party, the All India Trinamool Congress (AITC).
The production sounds modest (likely from a devotional album or live studio recording), which suits the intimate, questioning nature of the song. However, the core narrative of E Kemon Mamata
Following his retirement, Ghosh aligned himself with the newly formed All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) led by Mamata Banerjee. He spent roughly 13 years within her inner circle, gaining a front-row seat to the party’s planning, logic, and ultimate rise to power in West Bengal. Core Themes and Key Revelations in the Book 1. Unfulfilled Promises and Populist Rhetoric
As an elite IAS officer, Ghosh possessed a deep structural understanding of government policy, constitutional boundaries, and administrative ethics.
The book gained notoriety for its "unfiltered narrative" of Banerjee’s rise to power and its claims about her personal and political conduct.
(translated as "What kind of Mamata is this?") is a controversial political exposé written by Dipak Kumar Ghosh , a retired Indian Administrative Service (IAS) officer and former member of the All India Trinamool Congress (AITC). Published as a critical insider account, the book scrutinizes the public persona, leadership style, and political decisions of West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee . Ghosh’s writings, which also include related volumes like
:
Ghosh argues that many of Mamata Banerjee’s promises were "illogical" and meant solely to raise hopes without the intent or means to fulfill them.
– In recent years, Bengali Facebook and YouTube have seen short emotional verses or status updates with this phrase, often expressing sarcasm or disappointment at a loved one’s behavior. If that is the case, the phrase is informal and not part of established literature or music.
The story of E Kemon Mamata is not an isolated one. The TMC has accused other political figures, such as BJP leader Dilip Ghosh, of making "controversial remarks" against the Chief Minister. Likewise, BJP leaders have accused Banerjee of fostering "divisive politics," reflecting the deep political polarization in the state.
Upon its release, "E Kemon Mamata" immediately caused a political firestorm in West Bengal. The ruling Trinamool Congress quickly dismissed the book as a political vendetta. TMC spokesperson Jay Prakash Majumdar told ThePrint that the book "lacks credible evidence and was written with the intention to malign". However, he confirmed the government did not ban the book, claiming a belief in freedom of speech, but asserted the allegations were baseless.